Presslink News Aggregator |
[Alliance]First elections in the System Alliance since the reaper war to be held in Athens
Krishna Tram – Alliance News Network System Alliance spokesperson Tam Percin made an official declaration yesterday evening, announcing that test elections would be held in Athens in one month. “The Alliance is well aware that many of its citizens are concerned about the five years plan never actually ending, and want their voting power back. This is the first step toward that goal. In three months, the citizens of Athens will choose their mayor.” The choice of city of Athens, Greece, is not random, since human democracy is believed to have originated there. “We will try a new unified voting system. If it works, more elections will be organized so people can choose their mayors, then as the System Alliance passes the reign of powers, prefects and presidents will be chosen before the five years mark.” The declaration was met with approval, although critics said that it was nothing more than a delaying technique. Mr Percin went on to describe the system. “To implement this, and make the best of this opportunity to start from scratch, we have benefited from the expertise of Asari consultants. The asari people have lived for thousands of years in an e-democracy, and have kept updating their system all along. Their input will be vital in areas such as security and fluidity of use. Voting is the most important thing a citizen can do, so we can only accept the best technologies.” This declaration was met with mixed feelings. Many people expressed shock at the idea that aliens were consulted in remodeling the core systems of democracy. Isolationist parties have threatened to protest what they qualify as “selling out the heart of Humanity to the alien agenda”. At press time three political parties had registered for the race. Presslink News Aggregator: Collecting headlines from across the galaxy. ((Official administration news feed. Please consult the Site Rules for submitting an article.)) |
Mr_Sandman |
calamity21 wrote:While it’s odd that we could never come up with a common thing for earth in the last century or so, snow may be the one chance to overhaul the hardware completely and bring everything up to the best standard. Yes how dare earth deign to have multiple nations and cultures with their own methods of deciding upon their governing bodies, the shame. Well, some of you seem quite eager to abandon democracy right away. I think there are no laws prohibiting a vote against further votes? Repeat that once for each generation and have your go at it. What part of: Not Their Mandate do you have an issue with? One must therefore be a fox to recognize traps, and a lion to frighten wolves. -Niccolo Machiavelli |
IndigoIceMaid |
Looks like humanity has found a way to split the difference, rather impressive. It's not ideal granted. But it does defuse some of the seperatist/nationalist anger, giving SATAE more wiggle room and for a military junta, that is a good thing, one less thing for the civilans to bitch about, unless the perception is reality is the norm for all Alliance personnel.
|
Songbird |
this is literally the worst idea of all time
congratulations, satae you are officially dumber than i actually gave you credit for EDIT: I love how the only "mixed" reception that the article reports is the ever-loved strawman of THOSE DERN ALIENS and not how comprehensively fucked this idea is. |
Calypso Captain of the Faruq. Leader of the Damavand Corsairs. |
Khenti wrote:Ah, elections. The most fascinating and easily constructed placebo a repressive government will or has ever tried. Delectable.
"Hey guys, I'm just going to insert a witty comment with no context or data to back it up by some extremely obscure author you've probably never heard of." Adjusts Varren-bone rimmed glasses. "Anyway, now that I'm done contributing literally nothing to this discussion, I'll make a one worded sarcastic statement and then leave. Ciao" |
SteelUnifier Die for the Cause |
Calypso wrote:
Khenti wrote:Ah, elections. The most fascinating and easily constructed placebo a repressive government will or has ever tried. Delectable.
"Hey guys, I'm just going to insert a witty comment with no context or data to back it up by some extremely obscure author you've probably never heard of." Adjusts Varren-bone rimmed glasses. "Anyway, now that I'm done contributing literally nothing to this discussion, I'll make a one worded sarcastic statement and then leave. Ciao" Calypso wrote:
Congratulations on being literally one of the last people to have the credibility to complain about failing to contribute anything at all to an argument. SteelUnifier wrote:
Soldiers get paid, too.
In the case of the hierarchy, a whopping 0.00 credits per meritocracy tier. Hate to break it to you, but the turian military has been running on nothing but patriotism and promises for a year now. Not a very good situation for the morale argument, really. And "getting paid" isn't a binary state. Mercenaries get paid much more then rank and file soldiers do on principle. It's what draws the freelance wannabies in, unfortunately. |
Nat |
calamity21 wrote:While it’s odd that we could never come up with a common thing for earth in the last century or so, snow may be the one chance to overhaul the hardware completely and bring everything up to the best standard.
Who cares about culture and diversity and nationalism, right? calamity21 wrote:
Well, some of you seem quite eager to abandon democracy right away. I think there are no laws prohibiting a vote against further votes? Repeat that once for each generation and have your go at it. Yes, I hate democracy very very much and have no legitimate concerns about SATAE superseding its jurisdiction in this manner or how this system is a minefield both in practical and political terms. Fuck democracy. I'll just go smash the datapad with all the stuff from my political party on it right now. First Sergeant Natalie King, 2/4th Marines |
Khenti The world was not meant to be a prison in which man awaits his execution |
Calypso wrote:
"Hey guys, I'm just going to insert a witty comment with no context or data to back it up by some extremely obscure author you've probably never heard of."
"Calypso" leader of "Corsairs" is not, in the least bit, pretentious and hypocritical for grabbing at what is apparently (?) faux intellectualism. Adjusts Varren-bone rimmed glasses. "Anyway, now that I'm done contributing literally nothing to this discussion, I'll make a one worded sarcastic statement and then leave. Ciao" Political theory has existed for ages, fool. I would not be the first, nor the last, nor would I be a liar if I said that many forms of democracy - including definitively the one used by the Systems Alliance - simply do not work. Not even the Athenian democracy they seem so proud of worked. With the first elections, came the first rigged elections. You truly believe it's different now? Easier to rig and easier to avoid the consequences. Democracy. My. Ass. |
Max_the_Maverick Maverick! |
Ahhhh. It always warms my heart to see citizens openly and freely discussing the many facets and factors involved with building a successful and lasting democracy. It reminds me why I choose to become involved with politics here on the Citadel...
...I hope any of you that happen to live in District 69B in Tayseri Ward bring that same interest in democracy out on election day next year, to ensure I keep on fighting for you! Citadel Assemblyman Max Vallario: Representing District 69B, Tayseri Ward, the Citadel |
Mr_Sandman |
Max_the_Maverick wrote:Ahhhh. It always warms my heart to see citizens openly and freely discussing the many facets and factors involved with building a successful and lasting democracy. It reminds me why I choose to become involved with politics here on the Citadel... Oh my come off it. You're Hierarchy. Your home government isn't a democracy either.Nat wrote:Fuck democracy. I'll just go smash the datapad with all the stuff from my political party on it right now. Well I mean you are descended from convicts and killers so that's really just to be expected.<3 One must therefore be a fox to recognize traps, and a lion to frighten wolves. -Niccolo Machiavelli |
Max_the_Maverick Maverick! |
Mr_Sandman wrote: Oh my come off it. You're Hierarchy. Your home government isn't a democracy either.
Well, it may be true that the Hierarchy is not a democracy per say, but that doesn't mean I don't respect and admire the institution of democracy. Otherwise I wouldn't have bothered getting involved in the democratic process on this station, and put my success in the hands of the voters. And I do believe by the logic you're using, my friend, with anyone who was ever born in a non-democratic society not being able to appreciate or understand democracy, then I believe democracy among human-kind would have died out years and years ago. Though, you are certainly entitled to your opinion, on this station at least. Citadel Assemblyman Max Vallario: Representing District 69B, Tayseri Ward, the Citadel |
Mr_Sandman |
Max_the_Maverick wrote:Well, it may be true that the Hierarchy is not a democracy per say, but that doesn't mean I don't respect and admire the institution of democracy. Otherwise I wouldn't have bothered getting involved in the democratic process on this station, and put my success in the hands of the voters. You're getting involved because you were interested in an office on the Citadel first and foremost and Citadel politics adheres to the republican system in part by it's very nature. It's not like you had much of a choice.And I do believe by the logic you're using, my friend, with anyone who was ever born in a non-democratic society not being able to appreciate or understand democracy, Kindly stop manhandling my logic, I don't appreciate it and it's becoming intensely uncomfortable for everyone involved. What I was actually saying was that it's, frankly, somewhat hysterical for someone to promote unqualified democracy uber alles (and to the exclusion of all other systems) when ones native planet that they have no professed issues with is most emphatically not.I believe the relevant word is: hypocritical. One must therefore be a fox to recognize traps, and a lion to frighten wolves. -Niccolo Machiavelli |
Nat |
Mr_Sandman wrote:
Nat wrote:Fuck democracy. I'll just go smash the datapad with all the stuff from my political party on it right now. Well I mean you are descended from convicts and killers so that's really just to be expected.<3 Whereas you're still trying to escape the shadow of being descended from the West's boogeymen. The scars, augs and glowing green eyes really sell that. <3 First Sergeant Natalie King, 2/4th Marines |
Max_the_Maverick Maverick! |
Mr_Sandman wrote:
Max_the_Maverick wrote:Well, it may be true that the Hierarchy is not a democracy per say, but that doesn't mean I don't respect and admire the institution of democracy. Otherwise I wouldn't have bothered getting involved in the democratic process on this station, and put my success in the hands of the voters. You're getting involved because you were interested in an office on the Citadel first and foremost and Citadel politics adheres to the republican system in part by it's very nature. It's not like you had much of a choice.And I do believe by the logic you're using, my friend, with anyone who was ever born in a non-democratic society not being able to appreciate or understand democracy, Kindly stop manhandling my logic, I don't appreciate it and it's becoming intensely uncomfortable for everyone involved. What I was actually saying was that it's, frankly, somewhat hysterical for someone to promote unqualified democracy uber alles (and to the exclusion of all other systems) when ones native planet that they have no professed issues with is most emphatically not.I believe the relevant word is: hypocritical. Well, that's your opinion, and you are certainly welcome to it. ...Whether or not anyone will actually listen to it and think it's worth anything is up for debate, but you are welcome to it none the less. Citadel Assemblyman Max Vallario: Representing District 69B, Tayseri Ward, the Citadel |
Mr_Sandman |
Max_the_Maverick wrote:Well, that's your opinion, and you are certainly welcome to it. You know if your feelings are hurt you're more than welcome to hold discourse with us mere mortals and say they were. Frankly, we'd probably respect you more for that instead of, say, reverting to this weird blend of passive aggressive and ominous....Whether or not anyone will actually listen to it and think it's worth anything is up for debate, but you are welcome to it none the less. Nat wrote:Whereas you're still trying to escape the shadow of being descended from the West's boogeymen.
The scars, augs and glowing green eyes really sell that. <3 One must therefore be a fox to recognize traps, and a lion to frighten wolves. -Niccolo Machiavelli |
calamity21 |
Mr_Sandman wrote: What part of: Not Their Mandate do you have an issue with?
I have difficulties getting what you are referring to. Whose mandate do you mean, the politicians' or the voters' or something else?Nat wrote:Yes, I hate democracy very very much
My comment wasn’t directed at you.Actually, Nat, how are elections handled on Eden Prime? I know there are tensions up there, but do you people have a working political process or is there martial law? And how do you handle alien… well, non-human residents? I read up a bit on the history of the martian colony and it’s hard to believe that at one point there was no voting rights for resident non-humans! It is merely decades but for me this seems like from another space-time. Of course every permanent resident has a vote, not just humans. But the next colonial council will only be elected in two years, obviously there also was an emergency replacement vote last year for the vacant seats. But Mars is pretty small in comparison to everything, was even smaller back then. That’s easier to handle for SATAE, they are not very present in every day life really. Only double the paperwork when you have official business like applying for residency. |
Mr_Sandman |
calamity21 wrote:I have difficulties getting what you are referring to. Whose mandate do you mean, the politicians' or the voters' or something else? The Systems Alliance Transitional Administration on Earth. SATAE. The people ostensibly overseeing this debacle and who we've been talking about for theentirety of the thread more or less. Actually, Nat, how are elections handled on Eden Prime? I know there are tensions up there, but do you people have a working political process or is there martial law? And how do you handle alien… well, non-human residents? ...You do know what having a military government means right? She's under martial law. Earth's under martial law. The entirety of Alliance controlled space is under de facto martial law.Or did you just not notice all those posters calling him "Dictator Hackett"? But the next colonial council will only be elected in two years, obviously there also was an emergency replacement vote last year for the vacant seats. Can't imagine that the Director-General of Mars was thrilled at your little demonstration. One must therefore be a fox to recognize traps, and a lion to frighten wolves. -Niccolo Machiavelli |
calamity21 |
Mr_Sandman wrote:SATAE. The people ostensibly overseeing this debacle and who we've been talking about for the
I was talking about democracy and elections, don't know about you.entirety of the thread more or less. Mr_Sandman wrote:Can't imagine that the Director-General of Mars was thrilled at your little demonstration.
What demonstration? I am only on Mars for less than half a year now. You're kind of an extranet riddle, right? |
Mr_Sandman |
calamity21 wrote:I was talking about democracy and elections, don't know about you. I was talking about the people administrating said democracy and elections and why that wasn't a good thing. Why. Why is this difficult to grasp? What demonstration? I am only on Mars for less than half a year now. You're kind of an extranet riddle, right? General "your" given you are a citizen of Mars as well; plus said demonstration being that Mars is also under martial law with an appointed governor from the Systems Alliance and any officials voted into office have no real power and really serve no other purpose save as a vehicle for some political dick-waving.Which I can't imagine that said Director-General would appreciate given that it's basically a passive aggressive way of telling them to fuck off. One must therefore be a fox to recognize traps, and a lion to frighten wolves. -Niccolo Machiavelli |
Songbird |
I woke up and this still exists.
Frankly, I have no idea how they managed to so thoroughly manage to introduce a compromise that effectively fails to please everyone on both sides. No one who wanted elections wanted this unified, standardized, one-size-fits-all bullshit and no one who didn't want elections wanted elections. |
Nat |
calamity21 wrote:
Nat wrote:Yes, I hate democracy very very much
My comment wasn’t directed at you.Well you did say 'some of you seem quite eager to abandon democracy' when you don't have to be an evul anti-democracy separatist to have a problem with this development. Actually, Nat, how are elections handled on Eden Prime? I know there are tensions up there, but do you people have a working political process or is there martial law? And how do you handle alien… well, non-human residents?
Eden Prime, like the rest of the Systems Alliance, is under martial law. Everyone is under martial law, no exceptions. The colonies are not different to Earth. That said, a lot of day to day stuff is done by Eden Primeans who've been in place since before the war and now just send their reports to someone else. The police force still handles a lot of law-keeping. Aliens are treated under Alliance law, as they are in all colonies. Alliance law supersedes colony law as it always has. Non-resident and non-citizen aliens are treated in much the same manner as a human who is not an alliance citizen. Whether or not alien residents can vote in Eden Primean elections is kinda a moot point at this time. I read up a bit on the history of the martian colony and it’s hard to believe that at one point there was no voting rights for resident non-humans! It is merely decades but for me this seems like from another space-time. Of course every permanent resident has a vote, not just humans. But the next colonial council will only be elected in two years, obviously there also was an emergency replacement vote last year for the vacant seats. But Mars is pretty small in comparison to everything, was even smaller back then. That’s easier to handle for SATAE, they are not very present in every day life really. Only double the paperwork when you have official business like applying for residency.
Why is mars having elections? (And is it really so hard to believe aliens couldn't vote? Our first contact was violent and caused a lot of xenophobic backlash. As we got used to other sentients, that changed.) First Sergeant Natalie King, 2/4th Marines |